In my everyday conversations I very often hear a voice that is older than the person speaking.
It happens in a coaching session, in a meeting, over dinner. At some point a sentence arrives about what a man should be like, about what is expected of a woman, about what is serious and what is weak, and the person saying it does so as naturally as someone stating the obvious. It is the voice of the Patriarch, or of the Matriarch. Ancestral voices.
What strikes me most is where I hear them. They fill the conversations of the most evolved managers and of the most enlightened, open-minded helping professionals: people who have studied, who have worked on themselves for years, who often teach these very things.
And I hear them in myself. I recognize many. I recognize the Patriarch, who gives me boundaries and a sense of agency, the drive to act and to follow through, when I have a goal to reach. I recognize the Matriarch, who judges the weaknesses I sometimes do not allow myself to show.
I asked myself how voices this old can still live in people who have come such a long way.
Where they come from
I looked for the answer in my master’s thesis too, and it starts from something that readers of this newsletter already know. Each of us has Primary Selves, the parts we identify with, and Disowned Selves, the ones we set aside because, when we were small, someone made it clear they were not acceptable. We usually stop here, at our own story and our own family.
Except that our parents did not invent those rules. They received them from their own parents, who had received them in turn. Follow the chain back and you leave any single family and reach something that belongs to everyone: collective patterns, which Jung called archetypes.
Hal Stone was a Jungian analyst, and in the Psychology of Selves this idea has remained. Some Selves are born from our biography. Others are archetypal in nature and carry into us expectations, rules and prohibitions that are thousands of years old. They are the ones that steer, even before our personal story does, which parts we will easily recognize as our own and which will end up in exile.
The Inner Patriarch and the Inner Matriarch, described by Sidra Stone, are two examples among many: two voices that hand down to us what culture has always expected of the masculine and the feminine, and that on this basis promote some parts of us and reject others.
Why we hear them so little
This is where I find the answer to my question. A voice that comes from our own story is one we learn to recognize sooner or later: it has our father’s tone, a teacher’s words. An archetypal voice is much harder to hear as a voice, because everyone around us is saying the same thing. It sounds like common sense. It sounds like reality.
Sidra Stone shows this by comparing the Patriarch with the Inner Critic. The Critic goes after what we do: “it’s not good enough”, “you need to try harder”. The Patriarch goes after what we are: “a real man doesn’t cry”, “you’re only a woman”. To step back from the first, we rework the family script. To step back from the second, we have to notice an entire system of collective beliefs.
That is why I find these voices in the conversations of the most aware people I know, and in my own. Having worked on your own story does not shelter you from what comes from before your story.
Allies, as long as we can see them
I am not saying this to put these voices on trial. My Patriarch serves me well, and without him there are many goals I would not have reached. Archetypes are powerful energies, and they have brought us this far.
The difficulty begins when they drive without our noticing. That is when they can narrow our vision and lead us astray: when they decide on our behalf what is serious and what is weak, who deserves to be listened to, which part of us and of others has the right to speak.
Our part
This is why I believe we have a duty: to take responsibility for our actions and for how we interact with others, and to do our best to become more aware of the archetypes that guide our Selves.
Getting rid of them altogether is impossible, and it would also be a loss. Noticing when they are speaking, on the other hand, is within our reach. In Voice Dialogue this noticing has a name, the Aware Ego: the space from which I listen to the ancient voice and to the part that voice has silenced, and from which I choose, each time, how far to follow one and how far the other.
This holds for everyone. It holds twice over for those who lead people or accompany them, because a voice I have not recognized in myself is one I will hardly recognize in the person in front of me, and I end up agreeing with it.
Two questions are enough to begin, to be asked whenever we feel very sure about how someone ought to be, ourselves included. Who is speaking, right now? And what is it keeping me from seeing?
Where to continue
If, while reading, you recognized some of these voices and felt like listening to them more closely, Marzia Iori and I lead two programs designed for doing that together.
The Introductory Course to Voice Dialogue is the first step: two online sessions to recognize your own Primary Selves and have a first experience of the method.
The Voice Dialogue Facilitation Training is for those who want to learn to accompany other people in this listening, starting from their own.
Upcoming editions are always up to date here: https://www.dannybuccilli.com/en/training
Together, we get to know our Selves
Danny